"I have used several brands of gel eyeliner at several price points and this is by far the best one ever! Goes on very smoothly with the Illuminare Eye Liner/Brow Brush. Great coverage, lasts forever!"... (read full reviews)
"I've used Smashbox gel liner for years, but found that it dries out so quickly that you lose half the product. I started using Stila because it was the same price but the jar holds more product. PLUS"... (read full reviews)
"This is probably the best eyeliner Jane Iredale has ever made. I used to use the cream-to-powder liners but they contained some other shades that I didn't find useful. The pencils tended to drag along"... (read full reviews)
"The first time I used this pencil, I started writing my review in my head. This is it--the pencil to beat.
I've used lots of eye liners in my day and I finally found one that stays put. Once I put it"... (read full reviews)
"I only use Jane Iredale products because of the quality of ingredients/mineral makeup.
I have blue eyes and the basic brown really brings out color of my eyes.
Thank u Jane for another great product!"... (read full reviews)
"The Jane Iredale eyeliner delivers consistent results daily. Goes on smoothly and lasts all day. Best results require frequent sharpening with the Jane Iredale sharpener. A very good product."... (read full reviews)
"I love this eyeliner because it "stays put" all day and comes off easily, but the most important thing is that the brush is a fine sable type and I can control the width of the line very easily, which"... (read full reviews)
"I use the matching mascara and it removes as easily as stated, just run water over your lashes. The eyeliner is exactly the same, together you won't get a better set of products for sensitive eye."... (read full reviews)
"This is an excellent waterproof eyeliner. I have experienced less smudging with the Too Faced pencil, which is convenient. I also like that the TF pencil comes with a smudger on the other side."... (read full reviews)
"Very good product, the colour is a great brown with bronze sparkle, not too dark, not too light, the coverage is nice and it's the first time a liner doesn't go into my lashes, what I appreciate a lot"... (read full reviews)
"This is hands down the best eyeliner that I have used. I have tried many before and none are as smudge proof as this one. It still smudges a little as all liners do...but it's the best out there."... (read full reviews)
"This dark brown eye liner has some gold sparkle, but it's not bad enough to scare away this 50+ conservative lady. What I love most about this eye liner is that it goes on easily and smoothly... like"... (read full reviews)
"This eye pencil does exactly what is states in the description. It lasts a very long time. Also, the color Peacock is a beautiful color. I have brown eyes with a hint of hazel (only in the sun can the"... (read full reviews)
"I love this eyeliner and the dark brown gives a really soft, natural look. It's easy to apply and stays on all day and evening. It's great. Couldn't ask for a better product. Just wish it woud last a"... (read full reviews)
"Jane Iredale has wonderful products in general, but this eye pencil is a disappointment. I am not an oily skinned lady either but still, this pencil line slipped around on my eye lid and faded almost"... (read full reviews)
"I love the thickness of the pencil, easy to hold and apply to upper and lower eyelids. It really makes my green eyes pop. Great consistency, not too soft or too hard. Lasts all day and still looks"... (read full reviews)